East Hampton’s The Hedges Inn, a historic property listed on the National Register of Historic Places, has been acquired by Andrew and Sarah Wetenhall, the visionary duo behind The Colony Hotel in Palm Beach, Florida. Known for their dedication to preserving historic properties while infusing them with contemporary flair, the Wetenhalls are poised to breathe new life into The Hedges—ensuring it remains a cherished cornerstone of East Hampton’s story.

Sarah Wetenhall said, “As multi-generational property owners in East Hampton and current residents of historic Sag Harbor, we deeply appreciate the unique heritage of this special place. The Village of East Hampton is a true treasure, and we are committed to preserving its character.”
Steeped in history, The Hedges Inn was built in 1873 by John D. Hedges as a wedding gift for his bride, Caroline Isabella Homan. Over the years, it has become an integral part of East Hampton’s cultural fabric, exuding Victorian charm while serving as a haven for locals and travelers. For over three decades, the Cumming family maintained the property, building a legacy rooted in community and hospitality.
“The Hedges has long been more than just a property; it has been a cherished part of our family history, filled with memories and experiences that span over thirty years, “ said John Cumming.” As we transition into a new chapter, it is of great personal importance to entrust this legacy to someone with deep appreciation for the unique charm and history of East Hampton to ensure that the essence of The Hedges will be maintained. The Wetenhall family exceeds that wish.”
The Wetenhalls have mastered the delicate balance of preserving historical charm while introducing contemporary luxury. Their stewardship of The Colony Hotel has earned accolades including a spot on the Condé Nast Traveller Gold List and recognition as the #1 hotel in Florida by Condé Nast Traveller Readers’ Choice Awards.
“Our purchase of The Hedges Inn is not just a real estate transaction; it is a commitment to protecting this important piece of our community’s history for future generations. As guardians of The Hedges, we are dedicated to strengthening community ties while honoring the village’s cultural heritage,” said Sarah Wetenhall.
The Wetenhall Family’s vision for The Hedges includes exceptional guest experiences, intuitive hospitality replete with personalized services, and an atmosphere that is friendly and welcoming to all. The Hedges East Hampton will offer a selection of the most-beloved amenities and partnerships from The Colony, together with bespoke programming that is unique to East Hampton. The culinary offering will blend sophistication with comfort, offering breakfast, lunch and dinner daily, and partner strategically with key local farmers and purveyors. Signature game nights, including bingo and trivia, will add a further community-focused element, and enrich The Hedges fun, nostalgic and somewhat irreverent atmosphere.