From Montauk to Southampton, the Hamptons boasts some of the most sought-after lobster roll destinations in the world. Whether you’re craving a buttery classic or a chilled, refreshing take on this seafood staple, we’ve got you covered. In this insider guide from Hamptons Social, we unveil the top five best Hamptons lobster rolls, offering everything you need to know—from menus to insider reviews and must-try recommendations.
We’ll also break down the current lobster roll prices in the Hamptons, a hot topic that’s made headlines in recent years. Keep in mind, lobster roll prices can fluctuate weekly based on the price of lobster at market.
The Lobster Roll (aka LUNCH)
Since its inception in 1965, The Lobster Roll, affectionately known as LUNCH, has stood as an emblematic seafood shack on the Napeague stretch. Its acclaim is widespread, and The Infatuation declared it the best in the world. Here, the lobster rolls come in two classic varieties:chilled, with a touch of mayonnaise, and warm, drizzled with butter. The Lobster Roll is a must-visit for anyone searching for the best lobster roll in the Hamptons. Our personal favorite is their lobster roll with mayo. but the one served with butter is sensational, as well.
The Amagansett location is closed for the autumn and winter and reopens for spring and summer. The Southampton location is open year-round.
Prices:
Classic lobster roll with mayo: $35
Hot lobster roll with butter: $36
View the menus:
The Lobster Roll; 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett; 32 Montauk Hwy, Southampton
Clam Bar
Not far from the dunes, the Clam Bar at Amagansett offers a no-frills dining experience under the open sky. Their lobster rolls — packed with succulent meat and just a hint of dressing — are a study in balance and restraint.
The Clam Bar is open from Spring through the month of October. It is closed for most of the off-season.
Prices:
Classic lobster salad roll with mayo: $42
Hot lobster roll with garlic butter: $44
View the menus:
Clam Bar; 2025 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett
Duryea’s Lobster Deck
In Montauk, the rustic fisherman’s haunt-turned-chic waterfront locale Duryea’s provides a polished take on the lobster roll. Here, the classic dish is served amidst white-washed tables and panoramic views of Fort Pond Bay, conjuring a scene that rivals the upscale vibes of St Barths.
Duryea’s is open for the spring and summer seasons only.
Prices:
Classic Lobster Roll with Mayo: $44
View the menu:
Duryeas; 65 Tuthill Rd, Montauk
Bostwick’s Chowder House
In East Hampton, Bostwick’s Chowder House delivers a casual yet refined lobster roll experience. The charm of the place lies in its unpretentious approach and its mastery of seafood staples, inviting you to linger over your meal as the summer day unwinds.
Open from the spring through October. Closed from November until the end of March or early April.
Prices:
Classic lobster salad roll with mayo: $34
Hot lobster roll with butter: $34
View the menus:
Bostwick’s Chowder House; 277 Pantigo Rd, East Hampton
The Seafood Shop
In the quaint village of Wainscott, The Seafood Shop blends the charm of a local market with the excellence of high-end cuisine. A favorite of Ina Garten, this specialty food store is a requisite stop for anyone seeking the authentic taste of the Hamptons.
Open all year-round for 7 days a week.
Prices:
Classic lobster salad roll with mayo: $28
They don’t offer a hot lobster roll option.
Menus:
Today’s Specials and Take-Out Menu
The Seafood Shop; 356 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott
In the Hamptons, enjoying a lobster roll is more than just a meal—it’s an essential part of the local experience. Our list of the Top 5 Best Lobster Rolls in the Hamptons serves as your guide to savoring one of the most popular culinary delights the East End has to offer. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a first-time visitor to the South Fork, these spots guarantee a taste of the Hamptons at its best.
